Impact traceability for credible Scope 3 reporting

Impact traceability for credible Scope 3 reporting

Companies in land-based sectors are exploring how to account for their Scope 3 emissions under the Land Sector and Removals Standard (LSRS) from the GHG Protocol. Within the LSRS, physical traceability is central to ensuring the credibility and integrity of GHG accounting. However, the Standard also introduces the concept of impact traceability as a potential alternative approach when physical traceability is unavailable or insufficient.

VCI’s new exploratory paper on impact traceability examines the systems and governance mechanisms that could enable impact traceability in situations where there is no physical connectivity between intervention outcomes and products or material flows within a company’s value chain.

The paper proposes a system architecture for impact traceability, focusing on five core elements required to support the integrity and interoperability of impact claims: (1) claim instrument specifications, (2) system rules, (3) standardized instrument data, (4) systems of record, and (5) exchange protocols.

As an implementation framework, these elements can help reporting organizations assess the robustness of different instruments and understand how emerging market solutions may support GHG claims.

The framework is designed to inform the development of multiple initiatives, including the forthcoming GHG Protocol Actions and Market Instruments (AMI) Standard, implementation approaches under the LSRS, commodity certificate systems, and other future Market-Based Instruments (MBIs) and/or Environmental Attribute Certificates (EACs).

Join the conversation in the MBI Program:

The role of traceability in Scope 3 inventory reporting

When accounting and reporting in the Scope 3 physical inventory, physical traceability is essential to ensuring the accuracy of reported emissions. It establishes the origin of products and material flows, allowing companies to demonstrate the eligibility of specific emission factors.

The LSRS clearly establishes that emissions and removals reported at more granular spatial scales within Scope 3 inventories (i.e., harvested field, land management unit and sourcing region level) must be supported by physical traceability.

However, in complex value chains, physical traceability following the approved Chain of Custody (CoC) models is not always feasible in practice. This creates a need to explore alternative pathways to credibly report the outcomes of interventions and incentivize landscape-level action.

What is impact traceability?

In the LSRS, impact traceability refers to an approach that links reported GHG impacts to specific locations or activities without requiring a CoC or other traceability system to provide proof of physical connectivity.

The LSRS defines impact traceability as:

“The ability of a company to identify, track, and collect information on the GHG emission or removal impacts of projects or interventions in the value chain of goods and services purchased or sold by the company, including upstream and downstream processes and products.”

Rather than tracking material flows, impact traceability can rely on attribution links (e.g., financial linkages, sourced volumes, intervention area), program participation, or broader value chain associations captured via MBIs. Its primary focus is the mitigation outcome generated by a process, project, or intervention, and the associated right to report or claim that outcome.

However, the LSRS does not provide further clarification on what constitutes impact traceability or how it can be operationalized.

The functions of physical and impact traceability

Physical traceability primarily serves to improve the accuracy of GHG accounting. As companies move toward more granular reporting, for example, from global or jurisdictional averages to sourcing region, farm, or field-level accounting, physical traceability ensures physical connectivity (and therefore accuracy) between the reported emissions reductions and removals and the underlying material flows.

By contrast, impact traceability enables companies to associate intervention outcomes or emissions impacts with their value chain without requiring a direct physical connection to products or material flows. This creates the possibility of generating highly precise claims (using intervention-specific data, for example) that may not necessarily correspond to the actual physical goods contained within the inventory boundary.

While impact traceability may therefore support the recognition of interventions and help scale climate action across complex value chains, additional safeguards are needed to ensure that increasing precision does not reduce the overall credibility, consistency, transparency, and robustness of GHG reporting and claims.

The role of impact traceability in reporting

While impact traceability may help demonstrate support for climate mitigation activities, the LSRS does not recognize impact traceability as a valid basis for Scope 3 physical inventory accounting. The LSRS explicitly limits current Scope 3 reporting to emissions and removals that can be physically traced to the company’s operations.

Impact traceability may become relevant in the context of a multi-statement GHG reporting structure that recognizes other forms of reporting outside the physical GHG inventory. This multi-statement approach is being developed by the GHG Protocol in the AMI Technical Working Group for the forthcoming standard, currently expected to be published in 2028. Until further guidance is established, these approaches remain separate from the core accounting framework defined by the LSRS.

This is also why impact traceability has emerged as a relevant concept in the LSRS and AMI context. There is a need not only to track specified characteristics through a product chain, but also to track mitigation outcomes that may be unbundled from physical products. These outcomes could support future market-based inventory approaches, GHG impact reporting, or other forms of reporting outside the physical inventory, depending on how forthcoming standards define their use.

A proposed framework: five elements of impact traceability

To operationalize impact traceability in a credible, practical, and scalable way across value chains, the VCI proposes a framework structured around five core elements:

1. Claim instrument specifications

2. System rules

3. Instrument data

4. System of record

5. Exchange protocol

Together, these elements establish a foundation for ensuring the integrity of claims, consistency across actors, and interoperability between systems.

Relations across the elements of impact traceability.

A complementary approach to GHG accounting

Impact traceability should not be understood as a replacement for physical traceability or physical GHG inventories. Rather, it represents a complementary mechanism that could enable companies to credibly account for intervention outcomes outside the physical inventory, while maintaining the integrity of inventory-based accounting.

CoC models, including Mass Balance and Book and Claim, may provide important implementation pathways for this function. Other governed MBI systems may also emerge as alternative structures, provided they establish equivalent safeguards for attribution, ownership, data integrity, reconciliation, and claims.

As standards continue to evolve, impact traceability could plan an important role in scaling value chain climate action, particularly in sectors where physical traceability remains difficult to implement at scale.

Download the full paper for more insights

Explore the systems and governance mechanisms that could enable impact traceability when physical traceability is unavailable or insufficient.